Personal Insurance for Jefferson and Surrounding Communities

Stauffer-Klug Insurance is an independent insurance agency providing insurance to individuals, families, and businesses throughout Jefferson County.

While our website covers many of the common forms of insurance, which we have listed below, there are dozens of additional forms and endorsements to cover special situations. If you are not sure what type of insurance you need, give us a call as we would be more than happy to sit down and have a talk with you and answer any questions you might have.

Common Forms of Insurance

Have a Question? Give Us a Call!

Took time with my insurance claim and Randy called Insurance Company and started to claim right away within two weeks we had the claim settled what's the other insurance company

Warren F.

17:44 08 Sep 19

Sarah K.

20:59 18 Jul 19

Nice hometown agency

Douglas S.

17:11 11 Dec 18

I waited too long to have Randy and Deb switch my policies over....wish I would have done this a few years ago! Service is always excellent and every phone call is answered quickly. I would definitely refer people here...thanks for the great service guys!

Michelle H.

10:56 22 Jun 18

When I bought my home in 2013 I shopped around for homeowner's insurance & Randy got me a better policy than anyone else including my previous insurer. When i added my auto policy, he didn't just slap the car on the same company. He worked up a better deal by finding that in my instance, having an auto policy with a different carrier than my home gave me the same coverage for less money. That was unexpected but welcome news. Thanks!

Jeff JJ G.

20:24 21 May 18

Heather R.

21:37 13 Dec 17

I had to find Insurance for a family with one son that has a less than stellar driving record. Randy looked both at individual and family rates with a number of companies, to find the best rate. We have our cars, house, moped, boat and camper with Randy and Deb. I refer whenever I get the chance.

Lucy R.

18:33 16 Nov 17

I call with questions and they always have or get me the answers. Reliable, friendly, professional. Referred other customers to them.

Mary Austin D.

20:08 31 Oct 17

Super easy to work with! Never had any issues! Very friendly!

Sam L.

20:05 20 Sep 17

Stauffer and Klug are very professional and easy to work with. They take care of all the details

Kris P.

20:27 10 Aug 17

We just moved both house and car insurance to them. Randy saved us a lot of money and both are very pleasant to work with.

Lucy Oakley S.

15:27 29 Jun 17

Had excellent response, both phone and email, when my car was damaged by a thief and wonderful, prompt service in making adjustments to policies. Very nice to have local service instead of a faceless entity.

Diane Lang P.

04:54 23 Jun 17

I have enjoyed working with Stauffer-Klug. They have always been helpful and kind with any questions I may have!

Caitlin G.

16:38 23 May 17

Saved us a ton of money!

nicole L.

21:04 17 May 17

Found me great insurance and great rates for my auto and life insurance- Thanks!

Kristina S.

18:54 17 May 17

I called last minute for home/auto insurance and they gave me the best price around and helped me out as I am a first time home buyer. They were prompt returning my calls and getting me the information. Very easy to work with. Thank you!

Becky A.

15:08 04 May 17

Always good experience. They are always helpfu and courteous and knowledgeable.

Bonnie N.

17:13 19 Apr 17

We dealt with Randy and found him extremely knowledgeable, friendly, and thorough.

Marcie T.

00:30 18 Mar 17

Love the fact they both are home town people. Know how to treat you so nice and respected. They got me a great deal and went over and above for me. Love that cause now a days businesses don't do that. But these two are great people and great insurance.

Suzy S.

00:48 17 Mar 17

Someone was always there to take our call and provided us with numerous quotes as we tried to decide what policy was best for us. They are very responsive and always made time for our questions. Randy was also willing to meet with us after business hours to review our options for consolidating policies. He was very gracious and willing to spend as much time with us as needed to make sure all of our questions were answered. We would recommend them hands down, any day!

Heidi J.

16:39 07 Mar 17

Great people! Genuine concern for what I needed. Always there to advise the best course of action. THANK YOU!

St. John's L.

14:12 28 Feb 17

Randy and Deb are very friendly and do a great job of helping you with all your insurance needs!

Ruth F.

13:53 28 Feb 17

Randy found me a policy for my Siding business that I could easily afford. I was treated like an old friend which is a good thing because that's what I am.

Russ H.

23:10 27 Feb 17

Erick R.

22:27 27 Feb 17

Most honest & friendly insurance agents I've ever dealt with. I'll keep them for as long as I'm in the area.

Jeff G.

18:29 30 Jan 17

They are GREAT! Always there when you need them. Very helpful. Great prices!

Lori S.

01:38 30 Jan 17

I'm thankful for all the help and support I've gotten from Stauffer-Klug Insurance. Randy and Deb find us the best rates, are exceptional in their service, and always cordial on the phone.

Philip K.

22:23 29 Jan 17

Randy cares about finding you the best rate and doesn't just stick you with a policy if he doesn't think it's worth it.

EJ C.

22:13 29 Jan 17

Deb and Randy saved us hundreds over our last company and got us better coverage. Friendly and knowledgeable! Good people-GREAT RATES!!

MarkandPam T.

11:27 23 Dec 16

Randy found great policies for our house and cars. After reevaluating our coverage later on, he managed to reduce our premiums by half. We had been paying American Family far too much for a long time. Thanks Stauffer-Klug insurance!

Patty Prust H.

22:42 22 Dec 16

Great people, Great service! Plus great rates!!!!!

AJ L.

00:49 03 Feb 16

Jeff S.

14:18 30 Nov 13

Jefferson County's Independent Insurance Agency

Stauffer-Klug Insurance is an independent insurance agency, which means that we work for you, not an insurance company. Unlike captive insurance agencies such as Farmers, State Farm, or American Family Insurance, we're independent, working for you, and representing many financially sound companies.

Because of our relationships with companies such as Acuity, Secura, Progressive, Integrity, and Sheboygan Falls, we're able to shop around to find the very best price for the coverage you need. While we can't honestly say that we've been able to find a lower insurance rate for everyone we've quoted, we can say that nine out of ten people that give us a call end up with the same or better coverage for less money.

If you're interested in a free, no-obligation quote, contact our office today or fill out a short quote request form, and we'll see what we can do for you.

Call Now Button

Personal Insurance for Jefferson and Surrounding Communities

Common Forms of Insurance

Jefferson County's Independent Insurance Agency

Our Hours

Proud Member of

Follow Us